So if you're interested, watch this space.
Meantime, here's a favorite painting I got to see close up not very long ago.
![]() |
| Edward Hopper, "Early Sunday Morning," 1930 |
A site for opinions and ramblings about art, artists, and specific museums around the world. A place for "Museuming." All writing is copyright, Gary L. Hoff. Images copyright their respective owners. Any resemblance to persons living or dead is completely coincidental.
![]() |
| Edward Hopper, "Early Sunday Morning," 1930 |
MoMA in 1948, and is still the only painting by Andrew Wyeth in the museum. We see a huge field, partly mown, and a distant, weathered house toward which the woman in the painting is turned. Although the house in the painting did indeed belong to Christina Olson and her brother, the model for the figure was Betsy Wyeth, the artist's wife. Nevertheless, Christina and her brother were subjects of numerous other works by Wyeth. But the Wyeth is an anomaly at MoMA; indeed, this is the only work by that late contemporary master owned by the museum.
ems very familiar. We see a wraith-like cypress towering above a village against a night sky that can only be described as fantastic, even perhaps troubling. The haloed stars and the queer, s-shaped structures in the sky have been variously interpreted as clear evidence of madness, or perhaps of toxicity to certain drugs. By the time Vincent painted this work he was deeply enmeshed in whatever illness (mental or physical) that would lead to his suicide by gunshot within a year. Still, this painting is probably one of the most reproduced images in the world of art. I love the chance to see it.
There is perhaps no image in art that has been so admired and probably so reviled as "Les Demoiselles d'Avignon," considered by many to be the most important work of the modernist era, Les Demoiselles was nothing short of shattering. Pablo Picasso painted this work in the summer of 1907, less than 20 years after the death of van Gogh. According to a museum publication, "the painting depicts five naked prostitutes...figures...composed of flat, splintered planes rather than rounded volumes, their eyes are lopsided or staring or asymmetrical, and the two women at the right have threatening masks for heads. The space...should recede [but] comes forward in jagged shards, like broken glass." This was the beginning of Cubism and a clear departure from realist painting. Clearly Picasso was influenced by African masks, and to him this painting was partly an exorcism of sexually-transmitted diseases (which horrified many in that pre-antibiotics era) as well as an aesthetic statement. Picasso called it "The Brothel;" the current name was coined by a well-known critic of the time. Despite its fractured appearance and lack of convention, this huge (8'x 7'8") painting was the result of literally hundreds of preparatory sketches and studies. Although I admire it aesthetically, I find it too full of the sexual anxiety and dislike of women that seems too often a part of Picasso.
less well-known that those above, but considered by many to be an important work. Henri Matisse made this in 1911, and for many it was baffling. The piece shows the artist's studio and includes images of several works he had completed recently. The walls of this studio, in contrast to those of his actual studio, are dark red and many of the items shown are not painted onto the red color but show through from underpainted areas. On one level, this work depicts the objects and paintings from Matisse’s studio at Issy-les-Moulineaux. The picture space is flat but perspective lines and outlines of three-dimensional objects give some clue to the actual space. According to some critics, Matisse's theme of "art in art" (paintings inside a painting), gained traction in this piece and followed him throughout his career. In truth, I find it an interesting intellectual exercise to look at the works of Matisse, but as art they have little effect on me. Matisse seems to have been a visual genius, but I'm not certain he and I speak the same language aesthetically.
mentioning Salvador Dali's famous "Persistence of Memory," from 1925. There are other works by Dali that contain melting watches, but this one is perhaps the best-known. The notes at MoMA suggest that the subject of this picture is time and its fleeting, tragic nature. In the middle is a rather amorphous and seemingly decayed creature, while all around, clocks and watches seem to melt and perhaps evanesce. I've always enjoyed Dali, perhaps because of his madness.
like the self portrait shown here from 1997. The brilliance of his idea, taking a picture apart, breaking it into pixel-like divisions that require painstaking attention to color and value, is undeniable. Here is a master at the top of his game. Wonderful.
As the best portraiture always should, this painting of Sir Thomas gives us a glimpse of his intractable personality, his clear intelligence, and his inner calm. More was Privy Councillor at the time of this portrait but would later become Lord Chancellor and in that capacity refuse to sanction the King’s separation from the Catholic Church. As he did nearly anyone who disagreed with him, Henry had More beheaded. The work hangs alongside the fireplace in the Living Hall, part of the original house, just as it did when the Fricks were alive. Holbein had a startlingly accurate eye, it seems, and his work bears close inspection from anyone who is interested in seeing how well a man could paint half a millennium ago. The velvet of the sleeve, the gold chain, even the stubble of his beard is rendered with exactitude and art. This is one of those paintings that you can study for a long long time. It’s one of my favorite portraits, and I always spend just as long as I dare loitering before it, wondering at the freshness of the colors and the astonishing facility of the man who put them down on this wooden panel so long ago. The painting is about 30”x24” by the way. On the other side of the fireplace is the less arresting portrait of Thomas Cromwell, Thomas More’s mortal enemy. Unlike Sir Thomas, Cromwell supported making Henry the head of the Church and became one of the chief persecuters of Catholics for a few years until he inevitably lost his own head to Henry’s anger. Of the two, I like the More better.
Again, this one seems to have hung there during the Frick’s residency, as it does now. This large painting (about 42” x 36”) was painted a few years after the Holbeins, around 1590 or so, by El Greco and his helpers in four different versions. Another, nearly identical, is in the Metropolitan Museum, just up the road. El Greco, whose real name was Domenikos Theotokopoulos (his Spanish name just means “The Greek”), trained in Italy under Titian and painted in Rome for a time before settling in Toledo, Spain. Although I don’t know much about his life beyond that, his Mannerist works are always touching to me. Some experts have written that he was exploring religious ecstasy with his flame-like faces and hands, and perhaps that’s so. Whatever the painter’s motivation, the work in the Frick Collection is simply magnificent. Fittingly, across the room facing St. Jerome are two works by El Greco’s teacher, Titian.
The story goes that he painted many pictures of her and eventually lapsed into mental illness. This 1782 painting by Romney is titled “Lady Hamilton as Nature,” depicts Emma at about seventeen. It hangs in the Library, which is also the repository of Frick's enormous collection of books about art. When this was painted, Emma was already mistress to Charles Greville, who commissioned the portrait. She seems to have passed from her relationship with Greville to Greville’s uncle, Sir William Hamilton, whom she married. Despite being "taken," though, the active little minx also was in a torrid affair with Lord Horatio Nelson until his death at Trafalgar. Anyway, Romney painted about twenty portraits of Emma, being obsessed with her beauty. This one is quite lovely and fresh, and I like the dog a lot.
Painted around 1666 or so, long before the bright cadmium colors came along, this yellow robe nonetheless simply glows. This is the last painting bought by Henry Frick before he died in 1919. It’s a little mysterious because we’re let in on a scene where the maid is giving her mistress a piece of paper. The mistress is clearly the seated, richly-dressed and bejeweled woman. And she is apparently writing or reading something. It is tempting to supply one’s own narrative, perhaps even an illicit one. But there’s no indication of exactly what is going on. The mystery adds to the charm of this late work by the Dutch master.
The first one is “Portrait of an Elderly Man,” painted about 1627. In this portrait, Hals shows everything I enjoy about his work. His draftsmanship is impeccable and his brushwork has the energy and looseness that make us marvel at his facility. The reproduction here does little justice to Hals and makes a trip to the Frick almost mandatory.
This one is “Portrait of a Woman,” purchased about 1910 by Mr. Frick. It’s tempting to view this painting as pendant to “An Elderly Man,” and indeed they hang in the West Gallery as if they’re a pair. But then again, Hals painted many many portraits so it’s not likely these belonged together. Nevertheless, once again Hals’ mastery of portraiture is clear. Hals had a true knack for loose but expressive brushwork. He’s one of my particular favorites.
Rembrandt made perhaps sixty self-portraits, many brilliant. The most famous, perhaps, is the one in the National Gallery in Washington, painted a year afterward. In that painting, he has represented himself as an alert, intent man of affairs and appears younger than he does in this earlier painting. Here Rembrandt takes on the image of a ruler enthroned, holding a stick (or scepter) and wearing richly embroidered, golden garments. And the image is of a world-weary man who has by this time in his life seen everything and found it wanting. This painting also hangs in the West Gallery and unlike a number of other self-portraits by Rembrandt, this one is quite large and quite imposing at about 52”x 40”.Today the institute is called (rather grandly) Gilcrease Museum of the Americas, but the core of the collection is still Remington and Russell, with a healthy dollop of other well-knowns, including Albert Bierstadt, Thomas Moran, and George Catlin, among others.
So lets take a look at some of the features of the collection. You can't talk about Western Art without talking about Frederic Remington. Although many think he must have been a westerner, Remington was actually from New York. During the late 19th century, he made a reputation (and a great deal of money) as an illustrator for various periodicals and books, but he yearned for recognition as a fine artist. Although Remington did briefly attend art school at Yale, he wasn't that interested and left when he was still only eighteen. Refusing to go back to school, Remington instead went west to Montana in 1881 when he was about twenty. The mythical "Old West" was already fading by Remington's time, but the hook was set and he would return numerous times to sketch and paint. Nevertheless, except for brief periods, he never lived in the west. 
The painting to the right, "The Stampede," is one of my favorites by Remington. It dates from 1908, a year before the painter's death, the period when he was intent on throwing off the label of illustrator. To that end, he began a series of extensive studies that resulted in a series of about 70 paintings he dubbed nocturnes. In these paintings, of which "The Stampede" is one of the finest examples, he throughly studied the color of night as he saw it. (For other examples, see the entry for the 2003 exhibition The Color of Night at http://www.nga.gov/programs/abstracts/remington.shtm .) If you look carefully, you can see too that Remington was a master draftsman. His animals and humans all have real bones, convincing anatomy, and personality. And he could render action better than many of his contemporaries. Note that the galloping horse has all four hooves off the ground. Clearly, Remington had studied the pioneering photographic work of Edweard Muybridge.
Although he made his name in painting, by the end of the 19th century Remington had also begun sculpting in bronze. The Gilcrease is rich in original bronzes by Remington and now hold 18 of his originals. Today you can buy reproductions via many
sources, and there is a brisk trade in fakes. But the Gilcrease pieces were all produced by the artist himself. To the right is a view of the one that I've always loved. Remington called it "Off the Range," but it has come to be known as "Comin' Through the Rye," which in my view is much more appropriate. Here we have four cowboys, probably fresh off a cattle drive, tanked to the maximum (hence the "rye") and having a great time. Remington originally sold these through Tiffany's in New York City.
Besides Remington, the Gilcrease has perhaps one of the finest collections of Charley Russell's work. Russell was perhaps as well-known as Remington a century ago, although today I suspect his reputation is less glossy. Russell, like Remington, was not a native of the Old West but instead was born in St. Louis. Unlike Remington, though, Russell went West and stayed there, emigrating to Montana in 1880 to become a cowboy. He seems to have had no formal art training, and in fact his reputation was of "cowboy artist" came after a small watercolor of his, painted in the early 1890s, was circulated by the owner of a ranch where Charley was a cowboy. A his fame grew, Russell made many friends among well-off collectors of his works, including actors and film makers such as William S. Hart, Will Rogers, and Douglas Fairbanks. He died in 1926.
My favorite from that first visit to Gilcrease is this one, aptly titled "Meat's Not Meat 'Til It's In The Pan," is one that caught my adolescent fancy, probably because the ti
tle is humorous and the painting clearly needs the viewer to add some narrative. Russell was never the great draftsman or colorist that Remington was, but for a primarily self-taught painter, he was damn good.
Gilcrease is also a repository of American history and anthropology. The museum holds one of the circulated copies of the Declaration of Independence, signed by Ben Franklin, among other documents and letters by Founding Fathers, early maps, and even correspondence from the family of Christopher Columbus. There is also an extensive collection of Native American artifacts--clothing, pottery, basketry, and weapons.
If you're ever in Tulsa, take a couple of hours and visit. It's well worth your time.
Perhaps because of Barnum, among others, people in the 20th century began to view museums as places where virtually any collection of items was put on display, rather than as places of contemplation and education. It's tempting to say that the Smithsonian Institution also contributed to the trend; its vast and eclectic holdings spread all over Washington and environs represent the ultimate museum. And besides the well-known art and natural science museums of today, oddball museums devoted to nearly anything you can imagine have popped up across the world. Today you can visit museums of cheese, museums of barbed wire, museums of Bad Art. It's arguable that museums today are more like Barnum's and less like Alexandria's.
Quite a few contemporary museums of art rely on blockbuster shows of popular artists or movements to attract more visitors and hence more income. It costs considerable money to run an establishment like the Museum of Modern Art in New York and if the institution wasn't endowed by a billionaire the way the Getty (in Los Angeles) was or is not run by a government the way the National Gallery in Washington is, then the huge sums and considerable publicity accrued by running popular exhibitions are very very important. So we see continual (and repetitive) shows of Impressionists or Post-impressionists. Or we have head-to-head shows of Picasso and Braque. Or we see yet another show of the work of the gloriously mad Vincent van Gogh.
Luckily, the best art museums in this country do occasionally organize shows of the lesser-known artists of past centuries and the present day.